江汉学术 ›› 2019, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (2): 58-64.doi: 10.16388/j.cnki.cn42-1843/c.2019.02.008

• 法律专栏_法治中国建设的新视域与新话语 • 上一篇    下一篇

中国司法职业道德建设的人性考察——以制度和道德的辩证关系为视角

曹志瑜   

  1. 景德镇学院 教务处,江西 景德镇 333000
  • 收稿日期:2018-10-09 出版日期:2019-04-15 发布日期:2019-04-01
  • 作者简介:曹志瑜,男,江西景德镇人,景德镇学院教务处讲师,博士。

Humanistic Investigation of Construction of China’s Judicial Professional Ethics:from the Perspective of the Dialectical Relationship Between Institution and Ethics

CAO Zhiyu   

  1. Academic Affairs Office,Jingdezhen University,Jingdezhen Jiangxi 333000
  • Received:2018-10-09 Online:2019-04-15 Published:2019-04-01

摘要: 法治是中国既定的治国基本方略,是中国近百年来顺应世界潮流、向更高社会形态迈进的一种政治选择。长期以来,对于法治进程中面临的机遇和挑战,学界习惯将其中的问题简单归咎于制度,忽视了根源于人性的制度和道德之间的辩证关系。中国自20世纪70年代末以来,在市场经济的高度物质化和商品化价值观的冲击下,法治表现出制度和道德之间关系不平衡的状况,凸显了以公正为底线的现代道德基础的孱弱性。继而,作为制度和道德在司法职业语境下的具体化,中国司法改革的基本路径就是建立保障司法机关依法履职的制度体系,然而也表现出司法制度和司法职业道德之间关系的殊离。司法存在制度体系和职业道德两个方面的问题,两者不可偏废。司法职业道德能够弥补司法制度的不足,指导、评价和规制司法行为。基于此,应当不要过度倚重制度,在坚持司法制度和司法职业道德并重的前提下,司法职业道德建设有望通过促成司法公正而成为司法改革和法治方略的先导工程。

关键词: 法治, 司法改革, 司法制度, 司法职业道德

Abstract: Rule of law is China’s basic strategy of governing the country and China’s century- long political choice to conform to the world trend and to move to a more advanced social form. For a long time, scholars,in face of opportunities and challenges in the rule-of-law process,tend to attribute all problems to institutions and overlook the dialectical relationship between institution and ethics,witch is rooted in humanity. Since the late 1970s, under the impact of highly materialized market economy and commercialized values,rule of law in China has presented a state of imbalance between institution and ethics,revealing the fundamental frailty of modern professional ethics which is based on the baseline of fairness. As the embodiment of institution and ethics in the context of judicial profession,the basic approach of China’s judicial reform was to build an institutional system that guarantees the judicial authorities to perform their duties in accordance with the law. However,this reform still separated the relationship between the two. Institutional system and professional ethics are the two sides of justice and both cannot be neglected. Judicial professional ethics can make up for the shortcomings of judicial institutions and can direct,evaluate,and regulate judicial acts. Therefore we must not over rely on institutions,instead,we must place equal emphasis on both institution and ethics. The construction of judicial professional ethics can promote judicial fairness and become a forerunning project of judicial reform and rule-of-law strategy.

Key words: rule of law, judicial reform, judicial absence, judicial professional ethics

中图分类号: