江汉学术 ›› 2019, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (5): 35-43.doi: 10.16388/j.cnki.cn42-1843/c.2019.05.004

• 艺术专栏_艺术史论新视野 • 上一篇    下一篇

论民族志电影制作者进入影片的必要性

陈学礼   

  1. 云南大学 西南边疆少数民族研究中心, 昆明 650091
  • 收稿日期:2019-05-12 出版日期:2019-10-15 发布日期:2019-09-12
  • 作者简介:陈学礼,男,云南陆良人,云南大学西南边疆少数民族研究中心助理研究员,博士。

On the Necessity of the Filmmakers’Appearance in Ethnographic Films

CHEN Xueli   

  1. Research Institute for Southwestern Frontier Ethnic Minorities,Yunnan University,Kunming 650091
  • Received:2019-05-12 Online:2019-10-15 Published:2019-09-12

摘要: 在民族志电影的拍摄和剪辑过程中,有的制作者愿意让自己的影像和声音出现在影片中,可是有的制作者采取拒绝进入自己影片的态度和立场。制作者应该在合适的场景、合适的时间点、合适的关系状态下进入到自己的影片中。理由有三:作为文化解释之媒介的民族志电影,应该呈现制作者和摄像机对被拍摄者的影响和刺激结果;民族志电影作为文化解释的证据时,只有呈现制作者进入影片的场景,影片才具有作为证据该有的可信赖性;作为跨文化交流结果的民族志电影,理应展现制作者和被拍摄者关系演进的过程,展现制作者和被拍摄者之间相互作用的场景。当然,民族志电影的制作者应该把握合适的“度”,不要为了进入自己的影片而在形式上“进入”。因为民族志电影应该是作为“人”的制作者,和作为“人”的被拍摄者之间相互交流、相互尊重、共同建构的一个人工产品。

关键词: 民族志电影, 文化解释, 跨文化交流, 电影制作, 电影拍摄

Abstract: In the process of shooting and editing ethnographic films,some filmmakers are willing to include their own images and voices in the films while others refuse to do so. This paper holds the idea that they should appear in the films they make in appropriate scenes and time and in their appropriate status of relationship. There are three reasons:as media that interpret cultures,ethnographic films should present the result of the influence and stimulation of the makers and cameras on those being filmed;as evidences of such interpretation,they will achieve the desired credibility only when their makers appear in some scenes;and as results of intercultural exchanges,they ought to reasonably present the evolutionary process of relationships and the scenes of interactions between the makers and the people photographed. Certainly, the makers must control the“appropriateness”not to appear in the films simply for the purpose of “appearance”. This is because ethnographic films are man-made products jointly created by the makers as “men”and the photographed as“men”through mutual respect and communication.

Key words: ethnographic film, cultural interpretation, intercultural exchange, filmmaking, filming

中图分类号: